FAQs on the Markets and Economy
What is CNR's outlook for equities?
Optimism has returned to equity markets with U.S. stocks rallying back to near record highs on the Fed’s continuing policy pivot, as well as better news regarding the U.S.-China trade dispute. This is typical of late cycle investing where gains are harder fought as uncertainty surrounding policy, and mixed messages about the expansion’s sustainability, cause market sentiment to swing strongly. We still have enough confidence in the economic outlook, and see sufficient scope for earnings improvement, to remain positive on the long running bull market.
However, per our late cycle playbook, we have taken the opportunity provided by recent market strength to modestly reduce risk in portfolios and have lowered our allocation for U.S. equities to neutral weight.
The U.S. economic expansion is aging, economic and profit growth is becoming more challenging, and the risk of recession has risen. Equity valuations also are beginning to look high, which is typical of the late cycle. Though bear markets historically have rarely been linked to high valuations alone, they do create a higher the perch from which to fall.
We still believe maintaining a portfolio of high-quality and dividend paying domestic companies is the best strategy in the current environment. But, as the cycle matures and risks rise, we will continue to take steps to protect our clients’ capital.
Is the consumer still a dominant part of economic growth?
Personal consumption, which makes up about 70% of GDP, continues to be the driving force of economic growth. In Q2, it grew at 4.7% and in Q3, looks like it will grow around 3.0%, well ahead of the 2.3% growth rate of the overall economy for the past year. The robust growth is attributed to the near record low unemployment rate, solid wage gains and ample access to credit. This strength is helping to offset weakness arising from trade policy uncertainty (exports, investment, etc.) and should keep overall GDP growth around 2.0% this quarter.
GDP - Consumption is made up of both goods and services and is reported quarterly (a month after quarter end). To get an idea of how the current quarter is progressing, we look at the monthly release of retail sales, which reports the sale of goods only, without services. This has been on a strong trend of late (chart), driven by stronger vehicle sales.
What did we learn from the Fed meeting?
The Federal Reserve Bank lowered the federal funds rate by 25 basis points to the median level of 1.875%. Interestingly, there was a level of discontent. Seven of the voting members approved the move and three dissented. Of the three objectors, one wanted to cut rates by 50 bps and two members wanted to keep interest rates unchanged. As for their outlook, both voting and non-voting members of the FOMC make their projections. The median is for no change in interest rates for the remainder of the year, yet seven of the 17 members want another cut to interest rates before year end.
The varying views may be the result of difficulties is projecting the economic outlook. Although the Fed agrees that job gains have been solid and the household spending has been rising at a strong pace, there are concerns about the soft business investment and weakening exports. What makes it even more difficult is the high level of uncertainty regarding trade policy. Fortunately, in the past week or so, some of the trade rhetoric has been softening. In October, there is a meeting between high-level trade dignitaries of the U.S. and China, and it should shed more light on the issue.
The federal funds futures market is split over the future Fed actions this year. There is currently a 1.71% probability of another cut.
Are equity valuations a concern?
Equity valuations, although still reasonable in the context of today’s low interest rates, are beginning to look high from a historical perspective and do require close attention. High valuations are associated with lower long-term returns and provide a higher perch from which to fall in the next downturn.
Per our late-cycle playbook, we have taken measures to reduce this risk by focusing on lower P/E and higher quality, large cap and dividend paying stocks. However, it is important to note that bear markets historically have rarely been linked to high valuations alone. Usually, a combination of other factors such as recession, aggressive Fed tightening, or some kind of external shock is needed.
Over the shorter term, research shows that valuations have limited predictive value, and that factors such as the state of the business cycle, profit growth, sentiment, and momentum all tend to be more important. As a result, equity markets can and have remained expensive for extended periods.
What is causing interest rates to fall so much?
Ever since the early 1980s, interest rates have been falling. At the time, the 10-year treasury note hit a peak yield of 15.8%. The primary force that has pushed yields down since then has been lower and lower inflation. Back in the early 1980s, the consumer price index hit a peak of 14.8%. Now it is 1.7%.
This year, interest rates have been falling across the yield curve (chart). Short-term interest rates have fallen mostly in response to easing of monetary policy by the Federal Reserve Bank. Longer-term interest rates have been falling due to the drop in short-term interest rates, falling inflation expectations and lower yields on other sovereign debt around the world. For example, the 10-year government bond in the U.K. has a yield of 0.63%, in Germany it is -0.51%, and in Japan it is -0.21%. There is more than $14.5 trillion in global debt with negative yields, a staggering amount. For global investors, the 1.77% yield on the U.S. Treasury note looks very attractive. These global investors have been buying large amounts of our debt, pushing up prices and pushing down yields. Not only have they benefited from the higher coupon income, they have enjoyed the rally in the USD.
What is City National Rochdale’s investment outlook?
Given our continued positive assessment of the fundamental backdrop, we remain positive on equities in general and continue to see attractive prospects in the opportunistic fixed income class.
Still, downside risks have increased somewhat and the investment landscape is growing more challenging.
Late-cycle conditions of slowing growth and greater vulnerability to policy missteps will require investors to change their approach and be more selective in their portfolios.
None of this means there are not more opportunities ahead for investors, but gains are likely to be more muted. At the same time, concerns over global growth, trade tensions and the path of interest rates mean markets will likely continue to be subject to periodic swings in sentiment and potential pullbacks.
Our equity and fixed income research teams have made deliberate risk-mitigating changes to help fortify client portfolios against the type of market turbulence we have recently experienced, while leaving them well-positioned to take advantage of opportunities that present themselves.